What Does Coherence Mean In Writing

What are the differences between cohesion and coherence in English writings?

Cohesion and coherence definitions

Get help with your research

Join ResearchGate to ask questions, get input, and advance your work.

Most recent answer

Ministry of Education Eritrea

Coherence refers to how the sentences in a paragraph follow each other reasonably - stresses the connection of ideas at the idea level. Cohesion refers to how the ideas of sentences and paragraphs stick together to support the controlling idea - stresses the connection of ideas at the sentence level.

All Answers (8)

Applied Science Private University

The definition of coherence and Cohesion depends on the field they are used. Coherence is based more on the logic of the ideas and how they are presented. Cohesion refers to the degree to which sentences are connected so that the flow of ideas.

Isfahan Azad University Iran

Cohesion refers to the links of textuality and helps the writer to put various linguistic entities to form a united whole; therefore, cohesion guarantees coherence which is in effect the quality of the text in being logical , consistent, and meaningful.

coherence

يشير إلى الترابط المنطقي في بناء النص أما cohesion

فيشير إلى الترابط الفني في نسيج النص

University of Human Development

Cohesion refers to the ties between the parts of a piece of writing and it is achieved through the use of cohesive devices, such as whereas, meanwhile, therefore, etc. and through reference. Coherence, by contrast, refers to the connection between the ideas presented in a piece of writing, i.e. it is the unity of the theme in a piece of writing.

University of South Carolina

Take this practical example:

After eating almost all of her doughnut, which she loves, my daughter says, "Mommy, I will not eat it, because I do not like doughnuts at all."

Her sentence is cohesive. The words are intelligible and used correctly and, she gave me a clear argument for not eating her doughnut: she does not like them. However, she lacks coherence. Her argument is contradictory. If she really did "not like doughnuts at all," she would not have eaten most of her doughnut in the first place. Maybe she meant to say she did not like that specific doughnut, or that she was full and she didn't want to finish that one, but not that she did not like them "at all."

Now, an example that lacks cohesion.

"Mommy, I no eat doughnut. I will not anymore. Mommy, I no like it. No doughnuts. Here. Not all."

I did not mention it above, but my daughter is only 2 years old, and her sentences are still chopped and lack clear connectors. We piece the parts together and understand her message because we know the context, but her speech is not cohesive. A stranger might have a harder time understanding what she says.

In academic writing pieces produced by students at any level, we can find signals of cohesion (the sentences and paragraphs flow seamlessly) and coherence (the ideas make sense). In many cases, the writing has room for cohesion and/or coherence improvement. For instance, once, a student of mine submitted an essay about life on Mars. His language was just fine, but his arguments against life on other planets was too much traffic, not enough health coverage, and the price of housing on Mars. His arguments were not coherent with the topic. Another student had better arguments. He mentioned the cost of the investment on scientific research, the poor atmospheric conditions, and the risks for human lives on Mars. Nonetheless, that second student needed to review the transitions between his paragraphs to make his essay flow more naturally. He needed to work on the cohesive devices.

I hope these examples are helpful.

Related Publications

Chien Ching Lee

Low English proficiency students have difficulty making their writing coherent. They tend to to be more concerned with language matters rather than making meaning. This may be because they do not have a mental representation of their writing. Tree diagrams help students to see the hierarchy of their ideas and how their ideas are related to one anot...

Coherence is an inherent element of all effective written communication and, hence, this study purports to investigate the manifestation of textual coherence types in a corpus of fifty answer sheets produced by Sudanese English majors at a large public university. The methodological underpinnings are based on Halliday's (1994) conception of the cla...

Got a technical question?

Get high-quality answers from experts.